Page 1 of Fight Club:R1 or R2?

DVDs & Films Forum

Fight Club:R1 or R2?

Spiny Norman (Elite) posted this on Thursday, 12th April 2001, 17:29

OK guys, finally biting the bullet for this title, but which which version is better in your opinion?

I`d veer towards a PAL copy(R2), unless you know otherwise....

Cheers to all in advance

SN

RE: Fight Club:R1 or R2?

The Minister (Competent) posted this on Thursday, 12th April 2001, 18:18

here is a web site that compares the 2 regions http://www.dvdrumble.co.uk/

RE: Fight Club:R1 or R2?

Spiny Norman (Elite) posted this on Thursday, 12th April 2001, 22:34

Thanks for that WWH.

Seems to go for the R1 on more commentaries ticket. Still in two minds though.

Anyone else have a preference?

SN

RE: Fight Club:R1 or R2?

cw2000 (Competent) posted this on Thursday, 12th April 2001, 22:37

R2 is cut (the beating scene)

Also bet that the hidden single frame penis shot has been removed from the UK version.

RE: Fight Club:R1 or R2?

Spiny Norman (Elite) posted this on Thursday, 12th April 2001, 22:59

Good grief!!!

4secs cut from it!!!

Well thats it then, its R1 for me!

Thanks CW2K

RE: Fight Club:R1 or R2?

ickle yoda (Competent) posted this on Thursday, 12th April 2001, 23:39

get region 1 . It does have the extra commentary plus isnt cut as mentioned before. Even although it is easier to buy pal region 1 is better and why pay same price or more for an inferior product, they dont deserve it for cutting out parts of it, best film ever oh yeh fight club is definitely a dvd essential

RE: Fight Club:R1 or R2?

jaxon (Competent) posted this on Friday, 13th April 2001, 00:35

Region 1 or 2, whichever one you go for, it will always be the best film in your collection. UNTOUCHABLE !

RE: Fight Club:R1 or R2?

Spiny Norman (Elite) posted this on Friday, 13th April 2001, 23:29

Thanks to all.

Ordered R1 copy today.

SN

RE: Fight Club:R1 or R2?

TheWildSheep (Mostly Harmless) posted this on Saturday, 14th April 2001, 09:46

Of course the penis joke at the end hasn`t been removed, why would it be?

RE: Fight Club:R1 or R2?

cw2000 (Competent) posted this on Saturday, 14th April 2001, 15:47

forgot to mention that the R2 version also loses 3 of the commentaries, and a deleted scene (Extended version of the scene cut in the movie)

Go back to DVDs & Films Forum threads, or All Forum threads