Stuart McLean(Reviewer) posted this on Friday, 17th March 2006, 22:14
Just listened to the eagerly awaited new Gilmour album. Oh dear....all the right bits are in the right places but this could be `Wish you were here 2`. Now, I loved that album on release (and have continued to love it for the last thirty or so years) but it`s something of a travesty that this once incredibly inventive guitarist is merely going through the motions. There are some `nice` but predictable moments on here and it all washes over in a pleasant way, but the Floyd were once an incredibly creative force. This is (imvho) `stuck in a rut` stuff. Why`s he doing it? He can`t need the money? What`s the point? :(
RE: Gilmour....oh dear!!
sj(Elite) posted this on Friday, 17th March 2006, 22:31
Quote: Why`s he doing it? He can`t need the money? What`s the point?I think, simply, he`s doing it because he wants to. You`re right - he certainly doesn`t need the money - he gives millions away. So the point I suppose is, erm, he wants to make music so he has. :¦ Yes, the album is OK and just seems to wash over you..
Ste
We will pay the price but we will not count the cost..
RE: Gilmour....oh dear!!
Si Wooldridge(Reviewer) posted this on Friday, 17th March 2006, 23:40
Quote: Yes, the album is OK and just seems to wash over you..
Maybe that`s the whole point...
-------------
News Editor and Reviewer www.dvd.reviewer.co.uk
Go that way, really fast. If something gets in your way, turn...
And those who dance will spin and turn, And those who wait will wait no more, And those who talk will hear the words, And those who see will fade and die, And those who laugh will surely fall, And those who know will always feel their backs against the thin wall...
RE: Gilmour....oh dear!!
Stuart McLean(Reviewer) posted this on Saturday, 18th March 2006, 08:55
Whatever the case, it`s as dull as dishwater.... (:¦ (pretend that`s a yawning smiley....)
RE: Gilmour....oh dear!!
Stuart McLean(Reviewer) posted this on Saturday, 18th March 2006, 08:56
Quote: Whatever the case, it`s as dull as dishwater....
...i should add imho!! ;)
RE: Gilmour....oh dear!!
Mikeonfreeserve(Elite) posted this on Saturday, 18th March 2006, 14:19
Went to see Shine On, a Floyd tribute band,yesterday and they were excellent.
Maybe Dave should too?!
But what has he got left to prove? He can play guitar like drops of molten silver, or like continents ripping apart.
So what, if he wants to Polly-wolly-doodle a bit.
As long as they get Pulse out on dvd soon!
RE: Gilmour....oh dear!!
Stuart McLean(Reviewer) posted this on Saturday, 18th March 2006, 16:13
I`m not talking about the man proving anything...it`s just that many people will be parting with their hard earned money for this much anticipated album...and it`s a disappointment from a man capable of so much more. This is almost EXACTLY what you`d expect from a Floyd covers band...
RE: Gilmour....oh dear!!
floyd_dylan(Elite) posted this on Sunday, 19th March 2006, 16:36
Gilmour is okay but Waters is way better I still think Amusement to Death is by far his best solo album.
floyd
RE: Gilmour....oh dear!!
sj(Elite) posted this on Sunday, 19th March 2006, 20:34
Quote: Amusement to Death is by far his best solo album.Come on, if it`s his best, get its title right. ;) Agree, great album. :)
Ste
We will pay the price but we will not count the cost..
RE: Gilmour....oh dear!!
gary white(Competent) posted this on Monday, 20th March 2006, 00:11
Up until yesterday I fully agreed with the "oh dear!!" sentiment,
But I give it another listen, and I surprised myself by actually enjoying what I was hearing.
