Page 1 of Difference between pro logic and 5.1 ?

Hardware Forum

Difference between pro logic and 5.1 ?

Bowf (Elite) posted this on Monday, 4th February 2002, 15:16

I`m interested in buying a new goodmans surround system. It`s the right price and it looks good. It`s a powered amp,centre,L+R and 2 rears for £139.00. I think it`s called the GHC50.
However it doesn`t decode 5.1.
It`ll do 5.1 if the player does, but my Tosh 210 doesn`t.
The Goodman`s bumf says if it doesn`t receive a 5.1 signal it`ll do it in pro-logic.
What exactly will be the result ? Will certain speakers be redundant ?
Is pro-logic crap compared with 5.1 ? All I want is cheap surround....would I notice the difference between pro-logic and 5.1 in a `blind` test ?

RE: Difference between pro logic and 5.1 ?

clayts (Elite) posted this on Monday, 4th February 2002, 19:00

The simple answer to whether you`d notice a difference in a blind test is a resounding, oh yes indeedy, guvnor.

ProLogic is essentially four signals : front left, front right, centre and a combined mono rear speaker track.

Conversely, DD or dts have independent rear left and rear right channels (and it does make a world of difference), as well as an independent Low Frequency Effect channel (the 0.1 bit of 5.1), or more commonly known as a subwoofer : your grunty, bassy explosive bits, fed to preferably an "active" subwoofer (one with it`s own amplification on board).

Avoid the Goodman, and go for a package that can handle a digitial or coaxial digital cable - buying ProLogic is pretty much a waste of money if you want the real deal as far as home cinema is concerned.

RE: Difference between pro logic and 5.1 ?

geoff g. (Competent) posted this on Monday, 4th February 2002, 19:47

a decent 5.1 is a yahama tss1 it decodes dd, dts, and dolby prologic and stereo l&r it cost`s £160.00 and has been given a good write up in what sat tv.. so for the extra £20.00 you are getting the full monty.. www.yahama.co.uk

RE: Difference between pro logic and 5.1 ?

cloonus (Mostly Harmless) posted this on Monday, 4th February 2002, 21:23

Hi
What does the tss1 sound like. Is it loud.

Thanks

Go back to Hardware Forum threads, or All Forum threads