Page 1 of episode 3: no qui gon jinn scene

DVDs & Films Forum

episode 3: no qui gon jinn scene

balboa22 (Competent) posted this on Tuesday, 1st November 2005, 12:54

i bought star wars episode 3 yesterday and when i checked the deleted scenes i found that there was no deleted scene with qui gon jinn i felt diappointed because i wanted to see him as a force ghost,is anyone else disapointed??

This item was edited on Tuesday, 1st November 2005, 12:55

RE: episode 3: no qui gon jinn scene

Steve Eason (Competent) posted this on Tuesday, 1st November 2005, 13:35

Cutting a long story short:

1. Even in the script he would only have been a voiceover, as the idea is that he has discovered how to speak from "the other side", while it will be Obi-Wan who first manages to reappear as a ghost-hence a surprise when the films are watched in 1-6 order by future generations (remember Obi first just speaks to Luke in Ep 4, and only appears in Ep 5).

2. The scene was written, but never filmed, according to producer Rick McCallum. Cynics insist that they intended to use it, but Liam Neeson refused to be involved, and a suitable mimic could not be found...

...we`ll most likely never know the truth, nor see a scene inserted into the Ulimate Box Set....

Go back to DVDs & Films Forum threads, or All Forum threads